Short Films
Can Men Be Raped In India? Watch Mard Ka Rape Nahi Hota
Short film, ‘Mard Ka Rape Nahi Hota’ by Ankur Nayyar attempts to seek the conversation about the lack of gender neutral rape laws in India. The film is directed by Yogesh Pagare.
Rape is one of the most heinous and prevalent sexual crimes in India. In 2021 alone, 31,000 rape cases were reported. These are only the reported and filed cases when we know that the real unreported count is very, very high. India has witnessed many moments of fierce protests against sexual violence. The Nirbhaya rape case was one such moment that brought the country together and even reached the folds of the global west. However, we might want to look closer into the spectrum of sexual violences. To make it easier, we can turn to Ankur Nayyar’s most recent short film, ‘Mard Ka Rape Nahi Hota’.
‘Mard Ka Rape Nahi Hota’ is an attempt at initiating a conversation around gender-neutral rape laws and recognising that men can be the victims of rape too.
Plot
The entire film is located in a police office, at the kernel of law and order, crime and punishment. We’re introduced to a man (played by Ankur Nayyar himself) stepping inside the police office to file a complaint. He hesitates in narrating the crime he’s here to get filed. After much rude pushes by the police inspector, he finally reveals that his girlfriend, who’s been cheating on him, has raped him. The police officer denies registering the complaint at the justification that “a man cannot be raped.”
The film further takes us to different perspectives, which pans out the idea that the Indian law only considers women as the victims of rape and ignores men as victims of it too. This means a man who’s been sexually assaulted has no protection from the law. Ankur Nayyar also highlights situations in which men are the victim of false rape allegations.
‘Mard Ka Rape Nahi Hota’: Ankur Nayyar Appeals For Rape Laws For Men
When Ankur’s character confesses that he’s been raped, the police officer and the surrounding constables burst into laughter. The beginning of the film itself presents the cruel idea that men aren’t seen as victims of rape. In fact, the police officer says that it is quite impossible for a man to be raped. However, according to some real cases, this isn’t quite true. In 2018, five men raped a 17-year-old boy. In 2021, a French woman accused another woman, Divya Dureja, of sexual violence. The Priya Patel case brought forth the reality that women too can be active participants in the facilitation of rape. Since Indian law only recognises rape for women, these above-mentioned cases fall out of the spectrum of rape, even for a teenage boy.
‘Mard Ka Rape Nahi Hota’, directed by Yogesh Pagare, appeals for gender-neutral laws which recognize not only women as the victims of it but also men. Moreover, Ankur Nayyar, through the short film, also demands security for people charged with fraudulent sexual crime allegations.
The Ongoing Debate
While the short film appeals for the same laws for men too, it misses out on the inclusion of the transgender community. There are no rape laws protecting the trans community which invisibilises the sexual offences committed against them. The film solely focuses on men and their victimization.
Moreover, there is a huge debate revolving around the difference between ‘rape’ and ‘sexual assault’. Many feminist groups perceive rape as an exclusive patriarchal crime in which women have been the sites of sexual violence through forced and non-consensual penetration or oral sex and the invalidation of that will put women in triple-fold danger. Many foreign states, on the other hand, use sexual assault and rape interchangeably.
Therefore, one can also wonder if Ankur’s character’s emphasis on ‘rape’ was rightful or not. He was emotionally and mentally blackmailed and threatened by her girlfriend of false rape charges, but many can comment on the loose use of ‘rape’ in such a context. It is, however, acknowledged that his confession of being raped was definitely used to highlight the stigma, shame, and disbelief attached to the idea of men as the victims of rape.
The demand to include gender neutrality in the Indian rape laws is asking for a change from ‘women’ to ‘persons’ to include all genders, who might be the victims of rape and sexual offences. Several groups and activists want a balanced set of laws that can maintain gender equality between all.
Disclaimer: This feature is not an endorsement by The Talented Indian. Viewers’ discretion is advised.
Short Films
Malota: A Filmfare Nominee Short Film
Krishan Hooda’s film “Malota” is a 15-minute short film that delves into the complexities of school life and critiques the rigid education system imposed on young children.
When you’re out for drinks with your school pals on a Friday night, what comes to mind? For me, it’s the lively times filled with laughter, skipping classes, sneaking lunch in the back seat, or having fun fights and arguments with my best friends. While I value having a good time, I do recall studying things like my fundamental rights as an Indian citizen. But one thing that doesn’t stick is how many times I had to memorize the area of a parallelogram.
Krishan Hooda’s film “Malota” is a 15-minute short film that delves into the complexities of school life and critiques the rigid education system imposed on young children. The film skillfully draws comparisons between these two distinct worlds, offering a thought-provoking perspective. Let’s explore it.
Plot
The film opens with a scene of a couple, played by Geeta Saroha and Vishal Dahiya in their domestic space. They are talking about serious issues such as probable corruption in the area. This has led to their depleting quality of life as a consequence. Due to the same, they want their child, Gulab (Vansh Mallik) to study well and find a better career plan for himself. However, his mother points out that Gulab’s interest in village activities. This highlights the psychological shift from traditional or rural to urban and modern in the parents’ minds.
Soon the scene shifts to Gulab’s school where he is asked to prepare the multiplication table of 12.75 for the next day. While Gulab is studying for the same, he gets distracted by his friends and spends the evening petting a newborn dog. This obviously results in no studies being completed. Afraid of the beating he’ll receive upon not answering the questions, Gulab decides to bunk school.
What follows next is the story of an innocent world through a child’s lens. The outlook is different from that of us adults and it is refreshing. Almost nostalgic and leaves you with a void and scope for introspection.
Analyzing Malota: A Short Film
Malota tells the story of a kid who wants to live life on his own terms. While his parents want him to focus on education and avoid the challenges faced by uneducated people, things don’t seem to work out as planned. It could be said that this happens because of our ingrained belief in a specific type of education from an early age. The current educational system often molds individuals into a standard corporate office person, lacking individuality and personal perspective.
The entire narrative reflects the multiplication table of 12.75, which is arbitrary to begin with and allows for a wide range of interpretations. While multiplication tables are useful to a great extent, there is so much more for young minds to learn about in education besides mere arithmetic. Often critiqued as limited, they serve as an extended metaphor for every formula teaching. They also highlight the arbitrariness within them, prompting a deeper exploration of mathematical concepts and their real-world applications.
Gulab learns about managing water flow and the fundamental principles of bridge construction through a hands-on approach. Interestingly, this approach lays the groundwork for his understanding of civil engineering. Despite being deemed as a waste of time, building an improvised bridge across a random village stream can greatly enhance Gulab’s prospects in his future career. Krishan Hooda’s “Malota” highlights the contrast between rote learning and practical education. He challenges the idea that undervalues creativity and practical skills in favor of standardized educational approaches.
Summing Up
Gulab’s journey in Krishan Hooda’s “Malota” explores the negative impact of a rigid education system. The system that values conformity over practical skills and personal development. The film raises important questions about the true purpose of education. It also supports a more comprehensive approach that promotes creativity, critical thinking, and individuality. It argues that education should prioritize practical skills, individuality, creativity, critical thinking, and personal growth instead of just memorization and conformity.
Short Films
Valu: A Marathi Short Film Exposing Politicization of Sand
Inspired by real-life events, Mayur Dharod and Vikram Aggarwal’s Marathi short film, Valu screens the politics of sand and water.
As a result of increasing corruption and inflation, many rural areas have been facing illegal sand mining. This leads to severe water scarcity, taking a toll on the farmers’ livelihoods that depends on destroyed water sources. Inspired by real-life events, Mayur Dharod (Producer) and Vikram Aggarwal’s (Director) Marathi short film, Valu screens the politics of sand and water.
Plot: Valu | Sand
The film opens with a scene of Vitthal, a farmer working in his field. His young daughter assists him. The film uses natural and realistic imagery to bring out the reality of the everyday lives of Indian farmers as a universal subject. While they continue their day-to-day chores, the family soon realises that their bore-well has dried up. This will lead to no water left for the field. Eventually, The farmer witnesses the illegal mining of sand, which has caused the river of his area to dry up.
Worried about the outcome of sand mining and its consequences on his livelihood, Vitthal decides to report the crime to the district collector. However, the politics of sand mining have its roots spread everywhere. Upon receiving an unsatisfactory response from the officials, The Farmer decides to take control of the situation. This soon leads to a shocking end.
Observing Valu: A Thought-Provoking Short Film About Indian Rural Issues
Shot in Solnapur, a village near Aurangabad, Maharashtra, known to be the hub of illegal river and sand mining, Mayur Dharod and Vikram Aggarwal mirror the water crisis in many regions of the country. Farmers are often viewed as easily susceptible to submission to various illegal activities imposed on them. The power equation and social structures repeatedly force them to be at the mercy of the higher officials, often involved in corrupt activities.
Exposing the reality of farmers’ lives and the difficulties they face at the hands of dirty politics, Mayur Dharod and Vikram Aggarwal effectively highlight one of the most important rural issues of the nation. The film involves careful dialogues, such as the conversation between Vitthal and the truck driver involved in the illegal business. While one is living in a disguise, the other is environmentally conscious and chooses to live the right way. Additionally, there is prolonged silence throughout the film. This prompts the viewers think about the situations taking place and introspect about the outcomes of various events involved. The quest for observation defines the need for the right provisions instead of turning a blind eye to the basics.
Summing Up
Indian rural areas are prone to many different types of illegal activities that essentially affect the lives of weaker communities, such as farmers. These farmers end up falling at the mercy of the ones above them, socially and economically, and losing their livelihoods. Mayur Dharod and Vikram Aggarwal’s 12-minute Marathi short film underscores the need for change in the legal and political systems. At the same time, it asks the audience to think about the actual future regardless ofselfish requirements.
The Marathi film won the People’s Choice Best Film award at the Athens Marathon International Film Festival 2020. It was a finalist for Best Film at the Human-Environment Care Film Festival in Canada the same year. Additionally, it was officially selected at the Festival Amnesty International Au Cinéma pour les Droits Humains in 2021 and the Oscar Qualifying Austin Film Festival in 2019. And there is reason for it. Watch the short film here.
Short Films
Reviewing Gunta: A Story of Dreams, Aspirations and Comfort
Directed by Tejas Sonawane, Gunta, tells a tale of navigating the complexities of urban life in pursuit of dreams and aspirations in urban life.
Directed by Tejas Sonawane, Gunta, a 35-minute long short film, tells the tale of two men on their different yet uniquely similar journeys of navigating the complexities of urban life to pursue their dreams and aspirations in the city of Mumbai.
The film opens with a morning scene inside Rahi’s (Ashish Verma) apartment. He has just woken up to a messy house and stinking utensils in his kitchen. This highlights his need for house help as most people in urban setups do in their busy corporate lives. Soon Rahi’s position in his office is brought to screen as he finds himself at the mercy of his ruthless manager, Indira (Rajshree Deshpande). The narrative shifts to Rahi hiring house help where he meets Gurpreet (Gurpreet Sandhu), who is changing jobs because he is dissatisfied with working as a construction worker. He expresses his concerns of not being able to cover his expenses in the minimal pay of 6000 rupees in a city like Mumbai but is instantly countered by Rahi.
The story reaches a comfortable setting where Rahi goes to the office and expresses his dissatisfaction with the job. On the other hand, Gurpreet learns the housework requirements and continues with his new job. He stumbles a lot and gets scolded by Rahi for the same but makes up for it.
Gunta: Observing the Narrative Between the Dialogues
The film effectively draws parallels between the hardships faced by Rahi and Gurpreet, two immigrants to Mumbai, as they strive to succeed in their own jobs and deal with the difficulties of city living. Their shared struggles and goals, despite their contrasting upbringings and social status, reflect the universality of the human struggle.
Essentially, Gunta addresses the deeply ingrained class patterns in Indian culture, emphasizing the inequalities and conflicts that are present throughout its structure. Rahi, who is a script writer and an aspiring director, is constantly at the whim of his manager. Alongside, he is fed up with the unpredictable and unfair dynamics of the film industry. Similarly, Gurpreet, who aspires to work in films, is trying his best to handle the challenges of his new job. He is unable to grapple with the employer-employee relationship and treats it more like a sibling bond.
Gunta stands out for its subtle depiction of friendship and cooperation in an urban setting. The bond between Rahi and Gurpreet develops beyond the conventional notion of employer and employee. It blossoms into a complex dynamic that relies on trust and understanding on both sides of the equation. The film portrays the complicated nature of their bond through their communications and introspective moments. This tells the audience about the tragic reality and the loneliness that exists behind the surface of city life.
Summing Up
Sonwane’s direction is subtle yet evocative and captures the reality of the multifaceted struggles within metropolitan cities. He cleverly handles intricate subjects like class differences and challenges in the workplace. By letting the characters speak for themselves instead of relying on preachiness or a didactic approach, the movie invites audiences to consider the realities of urban life and the pursuit of ambitions in a world that is changing quickly.
In conclusion, Gunta is a remarkable short film that leaves a lasting impression. It reminds us that while pursuing success can be difficult, in the end, it is the relationships we make along the way that keep us going in life. With its gripping story, excellent performances, and touching message, it provides a glimpse into the lives of those who dare to dream in the city of dreams.
Short Films
ADHD: A Much Needed Awareness
ADHD doesn’t shy away from highlighting how people in India to this day and age still focus on the “mental” part of “mental health”.
ADHD (Attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder) is a disorder that is pretty common and manageable. But what is not common is it getting diagnosed in India. And the reason is not because it is hard to diagnose. Rather the lack of awareness about this condition and mental health in general in India is what contributes to the higher percentage of it being undiagnosed. The short film ADHD highlights this beautifully.
ADHD: A Closer Look
In about 22mins, the short film, ADHD manages to capture the audience’s attention. And it’s all due to the way the storyline is executed. Having a star-studded cast helps in gaining attention, but it’s the storyline that takes the story forward. And the creators of this film, Shipra Arora, and Shivankar Arora managed to do just that by nailing it with a strong driving storyline.
The film did stand out in certain aspects that ensured that it carried the theme of spreading awareness, such as the narrator who is also a pivotal character in the story, breaking the fourth wall now and then. By using various scenarios from everyday life, like failing to wake up early, getting distracted easily by small objects while studying, and feeling overwhelmed, each scenario though seems small carries with them a layer of what ADHD looks like. And thus, help us understand the depth and complexity of this mental health illness better.
ADHD doesn’t shy away from highlighting how people in India to this day and age still focus on the “mental” part of “mental health”. They made an impact by not shying away from shedding light on this painful reality of digital India that otherwise would have continued to remain in the dark shrouded by the thin veil of social media mental health wokeness that only targets certain age groups of people. Not being as well-covered as mental health topics like depression and anxiety, ADHD demands people’s attention to the topic as it’s not as common as one may assume it to be.
Afterword
The brilliant acting with a strong storyline is what makes ADHD a must-watch for any short film buff. Anyone looking to create more awareness about mental health, especially ADHD should really consider broadcasting this video to help communicate the message better.
Short Films
Short Film – AUTSIE | Autism spectrum disorder
“Autsie”: A Heartfelt Journey of Self-Discovery: Sometimes the most beautiful symphony is found within a world of noise.
“Autsie” is a heartfelt short film directed by Raghunath S. Animesh. It offers a look into the world of Autism Spectrum Disorder through the eyes of its protagonist, Animesh, otherwise called “Autsie”. The film goes in-depth into the internal and external struggles Autsie faces daily, a young man who finds solace in playing the drums amidst the challenges of living with Autism Spectrum Disorder and the people that make his life challenging as well.
Autsie’s daily life is made a struggle by the people around him who misunderstand him and taunt him, particularly Anup and others who bully him extensively. Autsie’s journey is about coping with his condition and finding acceptance and understanding in a world that often fails to see beyond labels.
A Closer Look
At the heart of the story “Autism” is a powerful message of self-realisation. Autsie’s journey drastically turns when he is unjustly stopped from doing what he wants. This setback catalysed his introspection, leading him on a journey of self-discovery and empowerment.
The film captures the inner turmoil and resilience with the sensitivity and authenticity of Autsie. As he grapples with feelings of inadequacy and isolation, Autsie discovers the strength to confront his insecurities and embrace his unique identity.
The film underscores the importance of empathy and compassion in our interactions with individuals with Autism Spectrum Disorder. It serves as a reminder that beyond the labels and stereotypes lies a rich tapestry of human experience waiting to be understood and embraced.
The Take-Away
In a world where differences are often met with fear, ignorance and sometimes even aggression, “Autsie” urges audiences to cultivate a culture of acceptance and kindness towards individuals with Autism Spectrum Disorders. By shedding light on the journey of Animesh, the film challenges us to look beyond appearances and embrace the inherent worth and dignity of every individual.
In conclusion, “Autsie” is a touching film of resilience, self-discovery, and the power of empathy. The film calls for audiences to practice compassion and understanding through its compelling narrative and heartfelt performance. It reminds us that true beauty lies in embracing our differences and celebrating the unique melody that each of us brings to the symphony of life.
-
Editor's Pick3 weeks ago
Health Psychology: Nurturing Mind and Body
-
Editor's Pick2 weeks ago
Autism Acceptance Month: The Importance of Neurodiversity
-
Short Films2 weeks ago
Valu: A Marathi Short Film Exposing Politicization of Sand
-
Editor's Pick2 weeks ago
Throwback Thursday: Jyotirao Phule, The Indian Social Reformer Who Challenged The Caste System
-
Editor's Pick2 weeks ago
Alcohol Use Disorder: Awareness and Affects on Mental Health
-
Editor's Pick1 week ago
The Stray Dogs Tales: Rescue For A Cause
-
Editor's Pick1 week ago
Twilight in Delhi by Ahmed Ali
-
Editor's Pick1 week ago
Henry Louis Vivian Derozio: Bengali Social Reformer